SO9C7-20 Key Problems in Criminal Justice
Introductory description
This master's module will offer a critical introduction to key concepts in criminology. The module takes a theoretical and conceptual focus that seek to explore what is crime and why people engage in it, and considers how we have response to crime in contemporary societies. The module seeks to invite students to take a critical, activist approach to the problems posed by contemporary criminal justice.
Module aims
This module will discuss critical, theoretical and empirical
perspectives on the problems of crime and punishment today. It
aims to act as a comprehensive, critical introduction to the
discipline of criminology. It will incoporate historical, theoretical as well' as contemporary literature covering a broad range of key themes that consider what crime is and question how societieshave responded to it. The first part of the module will look at the
relationship between crime and its social context, aiming to
provide an overview of criminological theories explaining crime. The concept of crime will be explored as it relates to individual
conduct, economic factors, values, language and culture. The
second part of the module will look at key issues in criminal justice,
covering contemporary cases of discrimination, injustice and
ineffectiveness in addressing the problem of crime, but also linking responses to crime to broader socio-political issues. This part of the module aims to challenge how justice has so far been pursued in Western, liberal democracies, and to more generally problematise
key aspects of criminal justice practice, including: features of
policing, the function and practice of punishment, the
consequences of mass incarceration, rhetorics of criminalisation,
and the proliferation of notions of risk and dangerousness in
criminal justice discourse. This is followed by the last part of the
module, which aims to constitute a discussion of potential
responses or solutions to the problems examined earlier in the module. This last part seeks to provide students with the necessary conceptual and research skills through which to critically question the notion of justice in an unjust world.
Outline syllabus
This is an indicative module outline only to give an indication of the sort of topics that may be covered. Actual sessions held may differ.
- Week 1: Introduction: The concept of crime, its extent and its context
Part I: Explaining Crime through Criminological Theories - Week 2: Crime and the Self: Positivism, Determinism and the Birth of Criminology
- Week 3: Crime and Capitalism: Marxist & Critical Criminological explanations of crime
- Week 4: Crime and Values: Durkheim's Anomie & Merton's Strain Theory
- Week 5: Crime, Meaning and Culture: Labelling and Criminalisation Part II: Problematising Criminal Justice
- Week 6: The police: what is it for and who is it for?
- Week 7: The problem of modern punishment: its socio-political function Part Ill: Addressing Contemporary Criminal Justice Problems
- Week 8: The prisons crisis: expansion, reform or abolition?
- Week 9: Restorative Justice, Transformative Justice & Structural Change
- Week 10: Conclusion: Overview and Assignment Preparation
Learning outcomes
By the end of the module, students should be able to:
- To develop advanced knowledge in key theoretical perspectives explaining the phenomenon of crime;
- To demonstrate appreciation of current issues and debates in contemporary criminal justice;
- To advance students' research skills: in analysing secondary data in criminal justice, including trends and patterns in crime, sentencing and imprisonment; in reading and understanding complex theoretical material; and in engaging with contemporary ethnographic and qualitative research in criminal justice;
- To link theory, empirical research, policy and practice in criminology and criminal justice;
- To develop critical analytical skills to challenge current rhetoric in criminal justice and to enable good analytical skills in the field of criminology;
- To improve students' ability to work independently and critically on issues of crime, punishment and justice.
Indicative reading list
- Illustrative Bibliography
- Carrabine, E. Cox, P. , Fussey, P., Hobbs, D., South, N., Thiel, D., Turton, J. (2014) Criminology (Third Edition) (London: Routledge).
- Durkheim, E. (1893 [20141) The Division of Labour in Society. (New York: Free Press).
- Durkheim, E. (1975) "Two Laws of Penal Evolution." Economy and Society, 2(3): 285-308.
- Durkheim, E. (2013) "The Rules of Sociological Method.", extracted in S. Lukes and A. Scull (eds), Durkheim and the Law, edited by S. Lukes and A. Scull. (eds), (London: Palgrave Macmillan).
- Elias, N. (1994/2000) The Civilising Process. (Malden: Blackwell).
- Ericson, R. (2007) Crime in an Insecure World. (Cambridge, UK: Polity Press).
- Foucault, M. (1975) Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison. (New York: Vintage Books).
- Garland, D. (2001) The Culture of Control. (Oxford: OUP).
- Hale, C., Hayward, K., Wahidin, A., Wincup E. (2013) Criminology (3rd Edition) (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
- Liebling, A., and S. Maruna, S. (2005.) The Effects of Imprisonment. (Devon, UK: Willan).
- Loader, I. and Walker, N. (2007) Civilizing Security. (Cambridge: CUP).
- Maguire, M., Morgan, R. and Reiner, R. eds. (2012) The Oxford Handbook of Criminology. 5th ed. (Oxford: OUP).
- McLaughlin, E. and Muncie, J. eds. (2013) Criminological Perspectives. Essential Readings. 3rd ed. (London: Sage).
- Newburn, T. (2017) Criminology (3rd Edition) (London: Routledge).
- Pratt, J. (2002) Punishment and Civilization, (London: Sage).
- Reiner, R. (2007) Law and Order: An Honest Citizens Guide to Crime and Control. (Cambridge: Polity).
- Reiner, R. (2016) Crime. (Cambridge: Polity).
- Wacquant, L (2004) Punishing the Poor: The Neoliberal Government of Social Insecurity. (Durham NC: Duke University Press).
Research element
See subject specific skills outlined above. The module is research-led and weekly seminars will draw on research-based readings. Students will be evaluated via a book review and a research-based essay.
Interdisciplinary
The subject of the modules draws from scholarship in socio-legal studies, sociology, criminology and sociology, among other social sciences disciplines.
International
Case studies and examples discussed in the module will be from different jurisdictions, including as much as possible global South perspectives. Having said this, most criminological content that is accessible to students is Anglo-American. As such, it's likely that much of the reading material will draw primarily from the UK, US, Canada, Australia and South Africa.
Subject specific skills
Subject Specific:
- Explain the problematic nature of the concept of crime and be able to discuss its conceptual and contextual foundations
- Develop advanced understandings of key theories explaining crime as discussed in the discipline of criminology
- Demonstrate an understanding of the key principles, values and practices of contemporary criminal justice in England and Wales
- Show awareness of key trends and demographic data on who is arrested, processed and punished in the English & Welsh justice system
- Have a critical understanding of the function of the police, discussions on its legitimacy and accountability and have an ability to apply these discussions to current issues around racial discrimination
- Demonstrate an appreciation of the diversity and range of punishment and alternative justice approaches available in a global context
- Demonstrate an understanding of the historical, political, and colonial origins of the modern prison.
- Critically analyse the social, legal, political, and economic impacts of punishment
- Compare and evaluate different theories and logics of imprisonment and justice and understand the basis of current crises in the prisons field.
- Assess empirical evidence on successes and failures in criminal justice
- Demonstrate an understanding of key problems, issues and debates within penal policy
- Develop creative responses to pursuits of justice
Transferable skills
- Deploy text-and internet based research skills at an appropriate standard for Level 7.
- Understand and adopt reflexive reading practices
- Understand and adopt skills in policy evaluation
- Demonstrate adequate skill in locating, evaluating, summarising and applying scholarly information
- Undertake directed research for the purposes of producing written assignments
- Express points of view clearly and effectively in class discussions
- Engage in critical self-reflection about one’s own opinions and perspectives
- Understand the epistemological relevance of one’s own social location, personal experience and identity when approaching social, political and legal problems
- Deploy critical argumentation and debating skills
- Demonstrate an ability to work independently
- Develop team working skills and oral presentation skills.
Study time
Type | Required |
---|---|
Seminars | 9 sessions of 2 hours (9%) |
Private study | 182 hours (91%) |
Total | 200 hours |
Private study description
Study for this module includes reading the weekly assigned readings and completing the assessments.
Costs
No further costs have been identified for this module.
You do not need to pass all assessment components to pass the module.
Students can register for this module without taking any assessment.
Assessment group A1
Weighting | Study time | Eligible for self-certification | |
---|---|---|---|
Assessment component |
|||
1,000-word book review | 30% | 15 hours | Yes (extension) |
Reassessment component is the same |
|||
Assessment component |
|||
3000 word essay | 70% | 20 hours | Yes (extension) |
Reassessment component is the same |
Feedback on assessment
- In the last session of the module students will have the opportuntiy to share a short essay outline in class and will get feedback on it before submitting their assessed essay;
- All books for which book reviews are required will be discussed in detail during seminars, giving students many chances to discuss them and check their understanding on them;
- Every student will be offered an individual meeting outside of classroom hours which will aim to provide direct feedback and advice on their essay and or book review. This meeting is meant to also help the student construct and plan their own essay question;
- Once submitted, students will receive written, electronic feedback on Tabula on all parts of their assessment.
Courses
This module is Optional for:
- Year 1 of TIMA-L981 Postgraduate Social Science Research
- Year 1 of TSOA-L3PD Postgraduate Taught Sociology
This module is Option list A for:
-
TSOA-L3PW Postgraduate Taught Social Inequalities and Research Methods
- Year 1 of L3PW Social Inequalities and Research Methods
- Year 2 of L3PW Social Inequalities and Research Methods
-
TSOA-L3P8 Postgraduate Taught Social and Political Thought
- Year 1 of L3P8 Social and Political Thought
- Year 1 of L3P8 Social and Political Thought
-
TSOA-L3PD Postgraduate Taught Sociology
- Year 1 of L3PD Sociology
- Year 1 of L3PD Sociology
This module is Option list B for:
- Year 1 of TSOA-L30J Postgraduate Taught Gender and Sexuality
This module is Option list C for:
- Year 1 of TWSA-M9P7 Postgraduate Taught Gender and International Development