HI2H9-15 Surveillance States: Biometrics from the Border to the Bathroom
Introductory description
You are being watched and measured. And you are not alone. For over a century, a global web of state, commercial, and individual surveillance has observed and measured an ever-widening variety of bodies, situations, and spaces. As our bodies have become legible to authorities and to ourselves, they have come to serve as identity documents, markers of kinship, and signs of entitlement or otherness. This module will explore the ways in which new ideas, knowledge and technologies have enabled states, societies and individuals to identify and assess their citizens, police their borders, and generate self-knowledge. From the invention of the ‘average man’ in the 19th century to the rise of home DNA testing kits and biometric passports, we will look at what it means to ‘measure up’ in modern society, and ask: how, when and where should our bodies be subjected to measurement, by whom, and for what purposes? Case studies will include fingerprinting, DNA profiling, and the all-too-familiar bathroom scale; others will be selected by students.
Module aims
This module will build on knowledge and approaches gained in Year One to:
- Explore the ways in which states, societies and individuals have defined and observed 'normality', ‘health’, ‘disability’, and ‘abnormality’ in modern history;
- Analyse how technologies of measurement and surveillance help to define both states and citizenship;
- Examine how policy and politics respond to innovations in biomedical and technological understandings of our bodies;
- Train students to use material and/or visual culture as well as textual sources from across science, technology and medicine; and
- Expose students to key themes in the histories of medicine, technology, and disability.
It will also complement the Year Two Research Project.
Outline syllabus
This is an indicative module outline only to give an indication of the sort of topics that may be covered. Actual sessions held may differ.
Week 1. Introduction: What is counted counts.
Week 2: Who counts? The Observant State
Week 3. Measurement and Surveillance in Empire
Week 4. Measurement and Surveillance at the Border
Week 5: Measuring and Making Ourselves
Week 6. READING WEEK
Week 7. Life in the 'Counting House': Weighing up
Week 8. Life in the 'Counting House': Student Selected Component on Home Testing
Week 9. Life in the 'Counting House': Student Selected Component on Domestic BiometricTechnologies and State/Commercial Appropriation
Week 10. Conclusion: 'Count me out' and the Politics of 'Informed Refusal'
Learning outcomes
By the end of the module, students should be able to:
- Demonstrate a detailed knowledge of the history of key surveillance technologies and modalities
- Analyse and evaluate the impact of measurement on the generation of social and political norms;
- Identify, research and analyse physical objects and/or visual representations as primary source material to generate new ideas and interpretations
- Communicate the findings of independent research, adapting it to the needs of diverse audiences
- Analyse and evaluate the contributions made by historical and interdisciplinary scholarship to understandings of bodily surveillance as state-making;
Indicative reading list
Reading lists can be found in Talis
Research element
Students will incorporate primary research with material or visual culture into their applied tasks and essays
Interdisciplinary
We will be using secondary readings from history, political science, legal studies criminology, and sociology.
International
We will be examine the impact of surveillance technologies in the British empire, the USA, and Latin America; and of bordering technologies in Bangladesh, Pakistan, Europe and the UK.
Subject specific skills
Primary source analysis.
Research involving secondary literature.
Presentation of work orally and in multimedia or essay form.
Transferable skills
Communication of original research and analysis to diverse audiences;
Critical analysis of media representations of controversial topics AND/OR critical analysis of the embedded assumptions of physical objects, e.g. oximeters, height/weight tables, etc.;
Improved awareness of the role of STEM in shaping cultural and embodied norms of selfhood and citizenship, and reciprocally the role of political and cultural factors in shaping STEM.
Study time
| Type | Required |
|---|---|
| Seminars | 9 sessions of 2 hours (12%) |
| Tutorials | 2 sessions of 15 minutes (0%) |
| Online learning (independent) | 3 sessions of 30 minutes (1%) |
| Private study | 130 hours (87%) |
| Total | 150 hours |
Private study description
Students will undertake independent research and reading to prepare for seminars and assessments. The general expectation will be the reading and preparation of three texts (of article or book chapter length) or of a mix of texts and primary sources, for each seminar; this should take approximately 3 hours. The assessments will also require independent research, reading around 6-10 texts, and then preparing and presenting outputs in the forms described. Students will also be expected to complete independent online research on how three separate accredited archives or museums curate objects or visual representations as preparation for their applied task.
Costs
No further costs have been identified for this module.
You do not need to pass all assessment components to pass the module.
Assessment group A
| Weighting | Study time | Eligible for self-certification | |
|---|---|---|---|
Assessment component |
|||
| Final Essay - 3000 Words | 50% | Yes (extension) | |
|
policy briefing or academic essay |
|||
Reassessment component is the same |
|||
Assessment component |
|||
| Applied task: Curation (1000 words) | 40% | Yes (extension) | |
|
All students will identify and ‘curate’ (via a multimedia assignment of c. 1000 words) an object which exposes or amplifies themes of the module. Required skills for this will be taught in the module |
|||
Reassessment component is the same |
|||
Assessment component |
|||
| Participation | 10% | No | |
|
This will be assessed through participation in module discussions and the submission of one weekly study guide on the readings OR one interpreted media piece related to the themes of the module. Students may request reasonable adjustments if needed (e.g., assessment via written or oral participation only if special/medical circumstances apply). |
|||
Reassessment component |
|||
| Participation reassessment | Yes (extension) | ||
|
Students who fail to complete both aspects of the participation element will be asked to submit two interpreted media pieces, equivalent to 1000 word essay. |
|||
Feedback on assessment
Written feedback via on-line systems (i.e. Tabula) and optional but encouraged individual meetings (face-to-face tutorials).
Courses
This module is Optional for:
- Year 2 of UENA-VQ32 Undergraduate English and History
- Year 2 of UHIA-V100 Undergraduate History
- Year 2 of UHIA-V102 Undergraduate History (Renaissance and Modern History Stream)
- Year 2 of UHIA-V1V5 Undergraduate History and Philosophy
- Year 2 of UHIA-VM11 Undergraduate History and Politics
- Year 2 of UHIA-VM13 Undergraduate History and Politics (with a term in Venice)
- Year 2 of UHIA-VL13 Undergraduate History and Sociology
- Year 2 of UHIA-VL15 Undergraduate History and Sociology (with a term in Venice)
This module is Core option list C for:
- Year 2 of UHIA-V102 Undergraduate History (Renaissance and Modern History Stream)
This module is Option list A for:
- Year 2 of UHIA-VM13 Undergraduate History and Politics (with a term in Venice)
- Year 2 of UHIA-VL15 Undergraduate History and Sociology (with a term in Venice)
This module is Option list B for:
- Year 2 of UHIA-V100 Undergraduate History
- Year 2 of UHIA-V102 Undergraduate History (Renaissance and Modern History Stream)
This module is Option list C for:
- Year 2 of UHIA-V100 Undergraduate History
- Year 2 of UHIA-V102 Undergraduate History (Renaissance and Modern History Stream)
- Year 2 of UHIA-VL13 Undergraduate History and Sociology